His wife said she wanted a big family — but after a year of trying, her husband discovers the secret she'd been hiding since before they met

Couples often discuss their long-term goals before getting married. A 27-year-old man (u/busy_top6281)  thought he and his 24-year-old wife were on the same page about having a big family until he discovered her long-kept secret. Well, the couple met when she was 18, moved in together when she was 19, and had been together for 6 years before they began thinking of starting a family. The woman always knew her husband wanted kids, but after a year of trying, she still couldn't conceive and finally had to tell him a heartbreaking truth. The story was first shared on October 19, 2025, on Reddit. 

A hidden past

After three years of marriage, the couple began family planning, but after a year, when his wife couldn't conceive, the author decided to undergo a medical test. The results came back fine, but instead of being happy for her husband, the woman sat him down for a "serious" talk. She told him that she had a cyst in her ovary at 16, and during the surgery, there were complications, and the doctor had informed her that the chances of getting pregnant naturally were very unlikely. The woman knew it even before she started dating the author, but chose to hide it because she was scared of losing him. Upon hearing the news, her husband was numb and hurt and felt betrayed by her. He left the house and stayed with his sister for 3 days with no contact. The wife was devastated and begged him to talk to her, but he was not ready.

A second chance

On October 27, 2025, the author shared an update and revealed more about his wife's trauma. Her mom left her at 13, and she was raised alone by her father. However, after her surgery, his father became an alcoholic after falling into debt and blamed her for her situation. When the author's wife was 19, she again lost another parent and developed severe anxiety, abandonment, and trust issues.

"She said she didn't have the courage to find out more...and was terrified of losing me if I found out. She hoped for a miracle after reading stories of women getting pregnant despite similar issues," the author explained. The man was deeply hurt and told his wife to stay with his parents until he felt okay to have a conversation with her. However, by the second day, he realized he actually missed her. Even though he was in a tough spot, the author realized he loved his wife and did not want to lose her. "We're not talking much right now. I'm still processing it all, taking one step at a time," he explained. A month later, the author updated his readers that he and his wife were going to therapy and working on themselves.

Beyond white lies

A YouGov Omnibus survey revealed that almost half of respondents have lied to their partners at least once (49%), and only 19% haven't. Similarly, a 2016 survey by IPSOS Public Affairs showed that 64% believe lying is sometimes justified. Interestingly, 56% reported that it is okay to lie to avoid hurting someone's feelings, and a similar share (54%) said it's okay for parents to lie to their children about their own past misbehaviors. However, when it comes to the "big stuff," 81% men and 92% of women say that lying to a spouse is never okay. Given those views, the author's reaction to discovering what his wife had hidden is understandable. She kept a significant secret from him, one that had a major impact on the future they were building together.

 Removing a cyst does not mean completely infertile

Meanwhile, reacting to the Reddit story, u/WinterMortician asked, "I mean, I don’t understand a woman not being able to have kids being a deal-breaker for a relationship. Okay, ideally, you want your own offspring. If I were in this situation, I think if I were passionate about having a family, I’d look into other options then, like adoption or surrogacy. Isn’t that a possibility?" u/sudden_childhood_824 wrote, "So just adopt even if she can’t have kids! If you love her and she loves you and y'all have a good relationship, then just adopt! Many couples can’t have kids, but they have a great relationship, and they either foster kids or adopt..."

More on Scoop Upworthy

Man asks wife to cover IVF costs herself due to her infertility issues, sparking debate

Man kicks his pregnant fiancée out after her long-kept secret forces him to rethink their future

Husband says he's unsure about fatherhood and pregnant wife walks out on him without hesitation