Pilot hid his wife while proposing to GF of 3 years. She found two hidden phones, pawned her ring, and watched his case collapse in court

Open marriages may work for some couples, but it's not everyone's cup of tea. On August 13, a married couple stood in Judge Eboni K. Williams' courtroom along with "the other woman" (the defendant). Four years ago, John, an airline pilot, and his wife, Mrs. Kane, opened their marriage, but they agreed not to talk about their "friendships." John used the opportunity to date the defendant for three years. Six months after he proposed, one discovery turned her world upside down. The video was shared by VerdictFlix, and it had 6.6 million views, 149,000 likes, and 5,221 comments.

Hidden wife

Mrs Kane explained that John was often away from home because of his job. "I just never wanted him to come back home frustrated and angry," she explained. That's why they opened their marriage, so they could satisfy their own "physical needs" and "romantic needs." She added, "I'm good, as long as he comes back to me." A year after this arrangement, John met the other woman at Charlotte Douglas International Airport, where she worked as a bar manager. John and the woman began dating, and three years later, he proposed. However, he never mentioned he was married and in an open relationship.

'Babygirl'

John said, "I wanted to take the next step with her [defendant] to keep her in my life. Decided to propose to her, and she accepted the proposal." Judge Williams turned to the defendant and asked when she found out he was married. The woman explained that six months after they were engaged, she picked him up from the airport and went to her apartment. While he was in the shower, she heard a phone ringing. It wasn't hers, and it wasn't his either because his phone was on the table. Then she realized the sound was coming from his suitcase.

She opened it and saw two other phones. John had three phones in total: one he used for her, one for Mrs Kane, and another for someone he named "Babygirl." John was not only married; he had a fiancé who did not know about his wife, and he had another woman.

Shameless demand

The defendant did not confront him right away. The following morning, after he left, she wrote him a message and said that she found his two phones. She added, "I really don't want any excuses; I've seen all I need to see." She said she tried her best to love him and put him first, but apparently, her efforts were not reciprocated. She ended the text by writing, "If you ever come back to my apartment, I'm calling the cops on you." John dared to demand the engagement ring back. Instead of giving it back, she pawned it in anger. After hearing everything, Judge Williams declared John was in the wrong, and that he should pay the defendant $25,000 for the pain and suffering he put her through.

Seperate devices

Not everyone is a fan of open marriages. A 2021 YouGov survey found that only 26% of American adults were very interested or somewhat interested in open relationships. The majority (68%) were against it. Mrs Kane and John agreed to an open marriage, but the defendant never did, which was why the discovery broke her heart.

Besides, people do a lot to hide their infidelity. ClarityCheck surveyed 9,600 people across the U.S., the UK, the European Union, and Latin America. Respondents were given two scenarios and asked to choose which one they considered a more serious betrayal. 42% chose a sexual encounter that happened once and never again, while the majority (58%) said that creating a hidden number or account for later contact was a more serious betrayal. 31% of respondents confessed that they used a separate number, app, account, or device to hide their affair.

Zero disrespect

Viewers demanded that the ruling Judge Williams gave John was not harsh enough. @SurvivalHorrorMomster wrote, "His wife is just as crazy as he is!" @the.wellness.parlour pointed out, "The issue isn’t that they had an open relationship. The issue is that his wife knew that he would have other lovers. His girlfriend didn’t know he had a wife."

More on Scoop Upworthy

Wife admitted she'd been secretly seeing her ex for a year and asked her husband for an open marriage — he chose a different route instead

Dad accidentally sent his son a romantic text meant for another woman. It was in English — but his mother only spoke German

Woman was relaxing on a cruise when her friend spotted her boyfriend on the ship's live camera — with another woman