Olive Garden waitress was fired for questioning a missing $700 tip — until one bank alert exposed their scam
Brook Skyes' mother brought the issue with Olive Garden to light and the customer responded
Restaurant servers often depend on the customers' tips to make up a significant amount of their income. Imagine Brook Skyes' surprise when a regular customer at the Olive Garden in Fayetteville, Georgia, left her a $700 tip on a $30 tab. However, the very next day, the single mother and server was fired for accepting such a significant amount. On June 2, 2026, Buni Williams took to Facebook to share an update about her daughter's situation. The video racked up over 2,000 likes and 180,000 views on her page.
Tip turmoil
Skyes realized she received a large tip only after the customer left. However, her manager told her to write $0 on the tip line because it needed to be verified. The two managers gave her different timelines for the verification process, which made her wonder if she would get her money back. Clearly upset, Skyes asked her co-worker to handle the next table, but the manager overheard her. Pissed, he asked her to either do her job or leave. At the end of her shift, Skyes was given 20% of the tip, which was only $6. The management explained that she did not receive the full amount because of the restaurant's policy on tips exceeding $500. Moreover, Olive Garden said they did not fire Skyes for receiving the tips, and that they had already discussed the issue with her. The restaurant even called the cops on the server, but couldn't report Skyes because the police sided with her.
The truth unfolds
As Sykes' story went viral on social media, the customer himself reached out to clear up the situation. He immediately locked his card after finding out Sykes had been fired. He sent a text message to Williams that read, "They updated the original charge of $32 to $38 and some change, so only a $6 tip. Then tried to charge an entirely separate transaction of $693. That's not normally how tips come out, so on top of my card being locked, my bank automatically flagged and declined the charge." When Skyes and Williams questioned Olive Garden about the double charges, they redirected the issue to the customer, asking him to check with his bank.
Unfair treatment
Customers generally tip servers for their service, but in reality, most of the tip money never reaches them. In fact, in a San Diego County survey, over 77% of service staff reported having their wages or tips wrongfully withheld or taken. Notably, researchers found that women, like Skyes, and older workers reported wage theft the most. The server's story also raises a bigger concern: the infamous "tipping culture." While this customer willingly tipped the server, a survey by Popmenu found that 66% of American respondents are pressured to hand over a tip. In fact, 64% of respondents said they have tipped a worker despite poor service.
'Get a lawyer'
Meanwhile, people flooded the comment section with legal advice and congratulated Williams for standing up for her daughter. For instance, Teronica Dixon commented, "If Olive Garden still cashed out the tip and kept it, that's theft! I hope she got an attorney and doesn't take an apology from Olive Garden." Similarly, Monica D Wagner asked, "How is this legal? I hope she gets the money. I wonder if the manager took the money."
More on Scoop Upworthy
Expert shares five instances where tipping shouldn't be necessary: 'Everything is crazy expensive'
Share on Facebook
