Boss reluctantly agreed after underperforming employee asked for a demotion — her next quarter performance proved him wrong

An employee was promoted to a senior position after excelling in her job for about two years. But what could've been a life-changing career opportunity turned otherwise when she failed to keep up with the increasing workload and overwhelming responsibilities. Frustrated, she asked her boss (u/romil_17) for a demotion and requested to be sent back to her previous role. Her boss agreed and, surprisingly, learned a powerful truth about success and career growth. The boss posted the Reddit story on April 21.

The employee was great at her job, and so she got promoted to the accounts manager position only two years after joining the business. Her role changed, and instead of the usual operational work, she had to manage clients. For straight-up 14 months, the employee struggled with her new responsibilities. In fact, everything that could go wrong went wrong. "[She] missed deadlines. Communication with clients became stiff and formal. [She] started making mistakes she never made before," the boss explained.

Soon, the worker approached the boss and requested to return to her previous role. She confessed she was struggling and wasn't enjoying working with the clients. "My instinct was to say no because it felt like failure — hers and mine. Promoting someone and then demoting them feels like admitting a mistake," the boss explained. Despite the initial hesitation, they complied with the employee's request and moved her back to her original role without a pay cut. And to their surprise, the employee revived her quality of work within two weeks.

That incident taught the boss a profound lesson. They realized not every good employee can handle management, and not every promotion feels like progress. "The assumption that career growth means taking on more responsibility, more visibility, and more human management is a corporate framework that doesn't apply to everyone," they explained. Moreover, the boss confessed that they take a minute to ask their employees a simple question before promoting them. "Do you actually want this, or do you feel like you should want this?" they wrote, revealing the one question that now helps them choose the right candidate for a promotion.

A 2015 Gallup report cited by Leadership Mindset found that only 10% of managers are instinctively good at managing people, while another 20% can cultivate the skills with the right kind of training. Moreover, the survey revealed that 82% of managers are handling responsibilities that don't match their natural abilities. This explains that while a promotion with a greater paycheck feels like a dream, not everyone enjoys it, particularly those who lack the efficiency to manage the responsibilities.

Meanwhile, reacting to the Reddit post, u/slairf commented, "Sometimes, the right thing is to continue doing what you shine at — not everyone can up and transition into a vastly different job. It’s why job levels should exist; sometimes you modify a position to a QC position. If she’s excellent at operational pieces, maybe she should oversee the QC of operations. It gives her money, and she can spread her strengths to other pieces." 

Similarly, u/maintenancecalm7693 shared, "I have done exactly this at a past job, applied for a higher-tiered position, and absolutely drowned in it. Asked FMTO to go back to the old position, the uppers were a little upset but gave in. I thrived and became happy; the new manager is also thriving in the position. Not everyone is cut from the same cloth."

More on Scoop Upworthy

Team leader garners praise for motivating employee to quit after company fails to value his skills

'Undercover Boss' finds out struggling employee is neck-deep in debt — changes his life overnight

Employee cleverly stops 'evil' middle manager from profiling employees through an 'anonymous' test