Movers unexpectedly showed up to take woman’s childhood piano after husband secretly promised it to SIL — then SIL billed her the $300 minimum fee

Some objects hold memories, making them incredibly hard to let go of. On a Saturday morning, a woman (u/applicationno7121) opened her door to two men from a moving company. She was surprised to see a work order from her sister-in-law (SIL) with her address on it. Apparently, the men were there to load her childhood piano up and take it to her house. Confused, she called her husband for an explanation and found out who the real culprit was. The now-deleted post was shared on October 19, 2026, and it has since received over 9,000 upvotes.

Not ready to say goodbye

The author was puzzled when she saw the two men at her front door. Her husband was at his brother's house, so she had to deal with the confusion herself. But when she called him, he told her that her sister-in-law's daughter had been learning piano since September. He explained she had been using a small keyboard to practice, so he decided to give her his wife's piano. He also justified his decision, saying the author hadn't touched her piano since they got the house. The author was not ready to part with her piano. Her parents gave it to her when she was 12, and it held sentimental value. In her post, she explained she played it during Christmas when her mother made everyone sing. Because of these memories, she told her husband the piano was staying. He responded, "Fine, then you explain it to her."

A counteroffer

The next day, the author received a text from her sister-in-law, asking her to cover a $300 moving fee. The text read, "Since you sent them away, I think this one’s on you." Although the author had no intention of giving away her piano, she made her SIL a counteroffer. She insisted her husband's sister buy her piano at $1,400. "I’d take the $300 off, so she isn’t out anything for the movers. I meant that too. If it’s going anywhere, I’d rather it be my niece," the author explained. Her sister-in-law, however, didn't respond to her message.

Objects hold memories

People tend to hold on to certain objects because they remind them of certain people or moments in their lives. A study by Elise van der Hoven found that people's attachment to certain objects may come from the object's ability to "fulfil" their desire to preserve, represent, or bring certain memories back for them. A Mixbook survey also revealed that 75% of respondents found it extremely difficult to throw away a gift, photo, card, souvenir, or any other item given to them by someone they care about. Another 79% said they kept everyday items that remind them of a meaningful person, moment, or place. Going by the numbers, it made sense why the author was reluctant to give away her piano.

'He's the real villain'

People in the comments called out the husband for giving away his wife's piano. u/annetoanne wrote, "This is between your husband and his sister. Tell her to take it up with him because he’s too much of a coward to tackle this issue himself." u/cassowary32 commented, "Is your husband okay because what the f**k? He promised something that wasn't his, then left you to deal with it, then the sister tried to bill you for refusing her attempt to steal your property? What is going on in that family? NTA."

More on Scoop Upworthy

Woman refuses to sleep at boyfriend’s house after discovering his ‘sentimental’ pillow situation

Woman finds thrift store sweater with sentimental message from original owner's grandma

Woman stands up for daughter when partner tries to give away her room to his niece