'I think refunding at least $150 would be fair,' she said, claiming the tutor failed to deliver a perfect score.
When a student scores 94%, most tutors expect a pat on the back. Instead, one educator (u/sensitive-office-820) got the exact opposite. After spending six weeks helping their neighbor's daughter, Emily, prepare for finals, they got a message from her mother asking for a refund. The mother argued that since Emily didn't get a full grade, the tutor should refund $150 of the $300 payment. Shocked by the request, the tutor turned to Reddit on November 14, 2026, seeking advice on this unusual situation, which garnered over 15,000 upvotes.
Imagine tutoring someone's daughter for six weeks and this is your reward ?❤️
by u/Sensitive-Office-820 in CheckMyTurnitin_ai
The tutor agreed to help their neighbor's daughter, Emily, study for six weeks ahead of her final exam. In exchange, Emily's mother paid a $300 fee. When the result arrived, the hard work seemed to pay off, as Emily scored 94% in her finals. Just like anyone else, the tutor expected some gratitude and praise from the parent. After all, they had done a good job teaching their child.

Instead of gratitude, the tutor opened their phone to find a surprising message from Emily's mother. "I'm a little disappointed," the parent wrote after seeing the test scores. Although she acknowledged that 94% was a solid mark, she felt let down because Emily missed a few questions. "If she’s still getting questions wrong after 6 weeks of tutoring, then what exactly was I paying for?" She questioned. From her perspective, paying $300 meant buying a guaranteed 100% score.
The message quickly took an even more baffling turn. Given that Emily fell short of a perfect score, her mom asked the tutor to return half the money. "I think refunding at least $150 would be fair," she texted, claiming the tutor couldn't deliver a 100%. She ended the note casually, adding a quick "hope you understand" alongside a white heart emoji. Stunned by her request, the tutor went to Reddit, hoping for advice.
Most parents expect 100% results from tutoring. In fact, according to a survey conducted by Huntington Learning Center, 70% of parents across the United States stated that tutoring is needed for their child's success. Moreover, 43% believe that extra learning improves their child's learning habits. Meanwhile, another 45% of parents think that tutoring boosts their kid's confidence. This shows that even though parents expect a lot from private tutoring, perhaps demanding a refund for not getting a perfect score is insane.


Meanwhile, people didn't hold back in the comments as they pointed out how the fee shouldn't be proportionate to the child's results. u/Future_Armadillo6410 commented, "There are people who think teacher salaries should be based on student success." u/NGEFan suggested a savage reply, "I'm sorry you’re disappointed. Given her horrible upbringing, it’s a miracle she even scored above 50%. Given my incredible work, I actually think I deserve an extra 44% bonus."
Landlord sends renter $400 ‘Christmas Refund’ — but it’s his 'thank you' note that steals the show