She didn't want to play Santa for people who barely spoke to her...
Some families go all out with Christmas presents, while others keep it simple. But things get awkward when people expecting extravagant gifts choose the cheapest items for others. That is what happened between a woman (u/anxiousangel1974) and her mother-in-law (MIL). In her post, shared on November 18, 2026, she explained that her MIL gave her a chapstick and her son a LEGO set during a previous Christmas gift exchange. She assumed they were shopping for gifts in the same range this year, until she received two wishlists from her MIL. The post has since received over 3,000 upvotes on Reddit.
AITA for wanting to skip the adult Christmas gift exchange after my in-laws sent us $3,000 worth of wish lists?
by u/anxiousangel1974 in AmItheAsshole
The author's mother-in-law, sister-in-law, and brother-in-law were quite distant with her family. Nonetheless, she always made the effort to see them during the holidays. She explained, "They rarely ask about our son and honestly barely know him." Recently, her MIL asked them to plan a get-together before Christmas. She had planned to hold a gift exchange. The MIL also texted the author and asked what her son wanted. She asked, "Do you want a gift card to a place, store, restaurant, or certain gifts?"

The author's MIL sent them two wishlists, a personal one and another joint wishlist with her 25-year-old daughter and her husband. The author elaborated, "I opened them, and they were Christmas lists with direct links to every single item. Lululemon, Uggs, a $300 Alo coat, and $200 New Balance sneakers." It felt extremely imbalanced because she was asked if she wanted a "gift card," compared to gifts that started at $100. In total, the list was worth around $3,000. What made it more ironic was that last year her MIL gave her a chapstick and her son a LEGO set. The author knew she was not forced to buy the gifts on the list, but she couldn't see the point of an adult gift exchange since they barely talk the rest of the year. "I’d rather just get together for Christmas and do gifts for the kids," she said.
While gifts are a big part of the Christmas spirit, it is not everything. The 2024 Holiday Spending Report from NerdWallet found that 33% of Americans would rather spend time with their loved ones rather than exchange gifts during the holiday season. 22% said they even wanted to discuss limiting their holiday spending in 2024 with their friends and family. Similarly, 40% reported feeling pressured to spend more money on gifts than they were actually comfortable spending. The author had similar thoughts. She wanted the focus to shift from the adult gift exchange because the wish lists were a little too extra.


Netizens were quick to point out how silly it was for adults to curate expensive Christmas wish lists for themselves. u/blondetourage83 wrote, "NTA. Asking other adults(that you are not in a relationship with) for high priced gifts is f**king insanity." u/Subject_Counter_7880 added, "NTA. The audacity to send an extravagant wishlist to people they barely talk to is beyond hilarious. My parents, siblings, and I talk on the regular and we do a secret santa gift exchange with a $xx limit and randomly draw names online. It's not about how much we can spend on each other- it's the thought that counts."