Mom gifted daughter a $400,000 home with 'one hard rule.' Her boyfriend's 'tantrums' proved her mom right
The duo are not even engaged, but he felt entitled to have his name on his girlfriend's property
Money matters can sometimes reveal cracks in a relationship, particularly when big decisions come with conditions attached. That's what happened in a story shared on Reddit by u/Immediate-History917, who described how her 33-year-old boyfriend threw a tantrum after he found out that her mother was giving her a $400,000 Sacramento property without his name on it. The 30-year-old woman had been dating her boyfriend for three years but was not yet engaged. While their relationship was serious, the boyfriend questioned their future together after the author's mom set a condition for her daughter to receive the property. Shared on April 23, the post has received 7,700 upvotes and 7,200 comments so far.
AITA for accepting a property gift from my mom even though she won't include my boyfriend?
by u/Immediate-History917 in AITApod
The boyfriend was thrilled, initially
The woman explained that her mother had a rental property in Sacramento that she had contemplated passing on to her for years. She was finally ready to do so, but under one condition: the daughter would have to sign a document that kept the property in her name alone, even if she got married later on. This was likely a way for her mom to provide her a non-negotiable security net for any future troubles. When she excitedly told her boyfriend about the place, he was initially thrilled and talked about selling it so they could buy a bigger place for themselves.
However, "he lost it" when she revealed the stipulation her mother had set. He was offended by the decision, saying that she did not see him in her future. He also added that if his girlfriend accepted the property, it meant that she automatically agreed with her mother that they had no future together.
Sister's sound advice
The woman was confused about whether she should sign the document or not, so she turned to her sister for advice, who told her it would be "insane" if she gave up such a property. Her father also agreed with her sister and said that if her boyfriend really did care about her, he would not be bothered if his name were on the property or not. Even though the boyfriend was barely speaking to her, he tried to influence her decision by saying that his parents would never treat her the same way.
She pointed out the fact that they were not engaged, so it made no sense why he felt "entitled" to have his name on her property. She described his reaction to her statement, writing, "He said that comment proved his point, and he's been staying at his friend's place for the last three days."
What's legal?
The mother may have had her reasons while deciding the conditions under which her daughter can take ownership of the Sacramento property. The legal system in California is different for married and unmarried couples. In case of the death of a partner or separation, unmarried couples do not get the same benefits as married couples do. The partner would not be able to inherit property from the other without any legal arrangements.
Moreover, while live-in relationships are becoming common, they are less stable than marriages. A recent study found that roughly 50% of women entered their first union through cohabitation, with 40% transitioning to marriage within three years, while 27% ended the relationship and 32% remained together without marrying.
Viewers clocked the manipulation
Several people in the comments called out the boyfriend's reaction and manipulative nature. They advised the author to accept the property, but not to include her boyfriend's name. u/PieSweet5550 commented, "Your mother knows who your boyfriend is, and he’s the exact type of man she’s trying to protect you from. Greedy, controlling, and manipulative." u/ExtremeHairLoss added, "NTA. Choose the property. Your boyfriend is crazy for believing [that] being in a 3-year relationship entitles him to your family's generational wealth."
More on Scoop Upworthy
Woman considers ending relationship when boyfriend picks new boat over helping with debt
Husband demands wife share lotto winnings or go separate ways — and the internet's on his side
Share on Facebook
