'I thought she kidnapped you and raised you.'
Steve Carter had always known he was adopted, but he never imagined he was also listed as a missing child for more than three decades. In 2011, after hearing Carlina White's story on CNN, he searched MissingKids.com for a boy missing from Hawaii. His first search returned nothing. Then he changed one number — searching for someone missing for 33 years instead — and an age-progressed face appeared that looked startlingly like his own. He shared his story on the "What It Was Like" podcast on November 3, 2026. The video racked up 4.5 million views, over 39,000 likes, and 2,390 comments.
Steve Carter knew he was adopted, but never really thought of finding more about his past until he and his wife decided to have children. In 2011, he was on his way to work when Carlina White's story kept popping up in the news. Carter thought. "This has happened too many times today to not lead to something else." So, when he got to the office, he went to the missing kids website and filled in the details. He initially wrote his age as 32, but there were no relevant results, so he changed it to 33. "The first person that popped up was an individual by the name of Marx Panama Moriarty Barnes. The picture looked, oddly enough, just like me," he said. His actual birth date was a day away from the birth date on the website. Apparently, he went missing at 6 months old after his mom took him in his stroller for a walk. The stroller was found at a bus stop.
Carter sent the photo to his friends and asked them who it looked like. All of them agreed it was a photo of him. When he told them the story behind the photo, his friends with no children were happy for him, but friends with kids suggested he call the police. Carter also showed his adopted mom the photo, who immediately asked if he had contacted the police. He had been hesitant, but after a conversation with his wife, he finally called the police. She pointed out that his parents might still be looking for him, since they went through all the trouble to provide documentation for the website. When he told the police what he had found, they did not take him seriously at first. Later, they requested that he come to the police department for a DNA test. Three to six months later, it was confirmed that Steve Carter was indeed Marx Panama Moriarty Barnes.
After Carter's identity had been confirmed, he found out that family members had been looking for him all this time. The National Center for Missing & Exploited Children reached out to see if he wanted to meet his birth family, and Carter agreed. His first interaction with his sister Jenny was through a phone call. She was eight years older than him. After an hour-and-15-minute-long conversation, they realized how alike they were. After his call with Jenny, Carter took two shots of Jim Beam, then called Mark Barnes, his birth father.
Carter hoped Barnes would have answers about Charlotte Moriarty, his birth mother, but both men were surprised by the call. Carter introduced himself as "Marx," then Barnes asked how Charlotte was doing. Carter revealed that he had hoped Barnes would have the answer because he'd never met his mom. Barnes revealed, "I thought she kidnapped you and raised you." Carter told him he grew up in an orphanage until he was adopted by his parents.
Sadly, Carter never met his birth mother. The last time anyone saw Charlotte was the day she and he went on a walk. Everything Carter knew about his birth mom was from what his maternal aunt told him. He found out that his birth parents met on a beach and lived together. They had a "tumultuous relationship." Charlotte would disappear for days, and then come back to fight with Barnes. From what he knew about her, Carter described Charlotte as a "free spirit."
Charlotte's tendency to disappear for days was why Barnes only filed a police report two weeks after she and "Marx" didn't return home. He thought Charlotte took him to New Mexico, where her ex-husband lived. When they did not come back, he reported them as missing persons. The craziest part of Carter's story was the Moriarty family hiring a psychic to "find" Charlotte and Marx. "The psychic had said that we were murdered and buried on a mountain on the North Shore." According to Carter, the family eventually believed the psychic’s account and dedicated a memorial stone to Charlotte and Marx.
Carter was able to meet Jenny and her dad in person. But Barnes passed away before they could see each other. The father and son had been in touch with each other and called once or twice a month ever since they found out about each other. As for Charlotte, the letters Carter's aunt shared with him revealed "interesting and horrifying" things about her. She made it clear that she never wanted to be a mom, and if he had to guess, Carter said she probably passed away 20 to 30 years ago.
Man kidnapped as a boy finds his birth mom after 33 years — all he had was a hand-drawn map of home