Landlord asked tenant to move out early so the owners could move back in. Once he did, landlord threatened legal action for breaking the lease
'We did not agree that you could sign a lease on another property,' Kevin, the spokesperson, explained.
Things often get messy when people break their promises, especially in professional settings. On July 20, 2026, a person (u/acjSolo) and their wife received an email from their landlord asking if they wanted to end the lease early. The original lease was supposed to end on December 31, but the owners wanted to move back into their property. The author took Henry, the landlord's representative, at his word and started looking for a new home. When the tenants finally found one and submitted their 30-day notice, the landlord accused them of breaching their lease. The post, shared on October 7, 2026, has received over 5,000 upvotes on Reddit.
A hasty house hunt
In the first email, Henry sent the author a link to their available homes. After browsing through them, the author said they were looking for a "single-story" house. They also asked when the owners wanted them to move out, and Henry said there was no exact date. He added that the owners had no problem waiting until the end of the lease. However, Henry said the author must start looking for other options so they could move out early. "We typically require a 3-day notice," he explained. A few days later, the author emailed Henry about finding a new home.
Sudden change in plans
The author assumed they would move into their new home smoothly, but Henry's reply email stunned them. "We will need to follow the terms of the signed lease, with the move-out date remaining December 31st... Because of this, we are not in a position to release you from the lease early at this time," he said. The author could not believe their eyes. They already signed the contract and paid the deposit for their new home. So, they stood their ground and pointed out that they were given "explicit permission to secure another home and move out early" in the previous email. On top of that, their lease stated they could "vacate the property on or before this date (December 31)."
Kevin enters the scene
After Henry, someone named Kevin joined the chat. He responded to the author's email, saying they had asked them to communicate their move-out plans before signing another lease. But the author did not budge. They maintained the stance that they took Henry at his word and did everything legally. To this, Kevin said they may proceed however they want, but if they were forced to take legal action, they would. In September, he sent the author another email and told them they had to pay a lease termination fee worth one month's rent. The author refused to pay because they put in their 30-day notice on time, to which Kevin replied, "Your call. I've already informed you how we will proceed." After months of back and forth, the landlord finally agreed to "honor" their request.
Unprofessional proprietors
Dealing with stubborn landlords can be exhausting. A LendingTree survey found that 53% of Americans disliked their landlord because of communication issues, while 42% could not stand them because of their unprofessional behavior. The author almost had to pay a termination fee all because Henry could not articulate what he meant in his emails. He suggested the author find another home to end their lease early, but did not specify that they had to find a home within the landlord's property. This miscommunication led to the long-drawn email war between the author, Kevin, and Henry.
Netizens called out the landlords on their nonsensical logic. For example, u/Xanthelei commented, "That last message reeks of 'We took this to Legal, and they chewed our a**es off so bad it's hard to walk or sit down.' I laughed at the "'if you leave early we'll be forced to begin evicting you.' The f*ck are they thinking they'll evict if you're already gone?" u/zerosumratio wrote, "This is great. Formal and to the point. You never backed down and kept it ice coldly formal. Awesome of you and something to definitely take notes from."
More on Scoop Upworthy
Share on Facebook
