Woman realizes she’s been officially missing for decades after her father walks in 40 years later
Between 1985 and 1986, a 'final call' occurred between the couple, but then the wife and daughter 'vanished.'
In 1983, when Joseph Newton, who was hoping to move with his family to Georgia, returned home to find that his wife, Debra, and his three-year-old daughter, Michelle Newton, were nowhere to be seen, he immediately alerted authorities. However, after a long search, Michelle's case was closed in 2000, and it then entered the FBI's "Top 8 Most Wanted parental-kidnapping fugitives." Unbeknownst to him, the child had never been told her origin story. It was only forty years later, when her father showed up at her doorstep, that the now grown-up daughter realized she had been "missing" all along. On December 13, per CNN, Michelle reunited with her father after a 40-year hiatus.
In spring 1983, Joseph Newton made plans to relocate to Georgia with his wife and daughter. However, when he came home one day, he found that his wife had abducted their three-year-old daughter and left their home. According to WDBR, between 1985 and 1986, a "final call" occurred between the couple, but then the wife and daughter "vanished," as per the Jefferson County Sheriff's Office. This was followed by a custodial-interference indictment warrant. According to a missing flyer, the cops were looking at possibilities of Michelle's residence in Clayton County, Georgia, which was 20 miles south of downtown Atlanta. Unfortunately, after years of searching, in 2000, Michelle's case was dismissed when the "Commonwealth" of Kentucky failed to reach out to her father.
Despite Michelle's name getting removed from the National Child Missing Persons Database, in 2016, the case was reindicted after a family member "prompted detectives to reexamine the case." In early 2025, a now 66-year-old Debra Newton was spotted in Marion County, Florida, where she had adopted a new name. According to CNN, a Crime Stoppers tip suggested that the woman might be Debra. A detective with a US Marshals Task Force compared a recent photograph of the woman with a photo of Debra taken in 1983, and a Jefferson County detective confirmed that the two appeared to be the same person. After a DNA test using Debra's sister in Louisville matched the woman at 99.9%, cops immediately went to her home and told Michelle that she was not who she thought she was and that she was actually a missing person named Michelle Marie Newton.
According to Fox 35, Debra had remarried, built a new life, and retired to The Villages with her new husband. After she was identified, Debra repeated to her neighbor, deputies, and her husband, who came out of the house to get the dog, that she didn't do anything, but she got extradited to Kentucky, where she will be facing a custodial interference felony offense.
After discovering her real family history, she contacted the Jefferson County Sheriff's Office, which led to an emotional reunion with relatives she had not seen in decades, including her father. According to a 2001 report by the Office of Justice Programs, about 354,100 parental abduction cases occur each year in the United States. The report notes that most abductors are in their 30s, and most children taken are between three and five years old. It also highlighted that abduction can cause serious emotional harm to children and left-behind parents. Not having met his daughter for over 40 years left a scar in Joseph's heart; reuniting with his daughter healed him in unimaginable ways.
Overwhelmed with emotions, the truth was a bittersweet revelation to Michelle. As for her father, the reunion meant everything to him, comparing it to holding her as a newborn. While everyone expected Michelle to burst out at her mother, she believes in not taking sides. Speaking to Wesh 2 News, Michelle explained, "My intention is to support them both through this and try to navigate and help them both just wrap it up so that we can all heal."
More on Scoop Upworthy
Man kidnapped as a boy finds his birth mom after 33 years — all he had was a hand-drawn map of home
Share on Facebook
