'She gets the answer correct but doesn't show how she got the answer,' her father noted.
When a kid answers every question right on a test, they expect a full grade. That was the case for a middle schooler who breezed through her math test, only to be hit with a 50% and a zero on her homework. Her father (u/Throwawaysinf_4042) was initially ready to push back against the harsh marks, especially with his daughter and wife upset at the teacher. Then the teacher explained the catch. Once the teacher offered a fair recess retake, the dad realized the rule had a real point and sided with the classroom policy instead. He later took to Reddit to seek advice on November 16, 2026, garnering over 14,000 upvotes.
AITA for telling my daughter that she is being entitled and I am not going to talk to the teacher.
by u/Throwawaysinf_4042 in AmItheAsshole
Math always came easily to the girl. She could solve complex problems entirely in her head. So, to save time during exams, she started to skip writing the steps down. "She gets the answer correct but doesn't show how she got the answer," her father noted. It didn't matter much to her, as she just wanted to finish her work early and get extra time to relax. Her math teacher, however, noticed the missing steps and began to flag it to her parents. "The teacher has talked to her, and I have talked to her about it," her father explained. The girl argued that she didn't want to show the work since it's just easier to do it in her head.

After repeated warnings, the missing work began to affect her grades. Her father said showing the steps helped the teacher see whether she was using the expected formulas and whether the work was her own. So, even though she solved every problem accurately, she received a 50% on a major test and a zero on her homework. The grades upset her, especially because she was used to scoring 90% or higher. "The teacher sent home a note that my daughter could retake a similar test if she stays in recess," her father revealed.

The low marks left the girl deeply upset and crying. She felt the grading was unfair and asked her dad to step in and get the scores changed. Her mother was also frustrated with the teacher, which sparked an argument between the parents. Still, the father refused to intervene. He told his daughter she was acting “entitled” by assuming classroom directions did not apply to her. The father stood firmly behind the teacher's decision, even though it might have come at the cost of some peace at his house.

Many teachers say they want more parental support when it comes to student accountability. A Pew Research survey survey of U.S. public K-12 teachers found that 79% believed parents did too little to hold their children accountable when they misbehaved in school. Another 68% said parents did too little to help with schoolwork, while 63% said the same about ensuring attendance.


The people were with the father on this one, as they believe showing work is important. u/Proper_Inspection580 commented, "NTA. ' Show your work' has been a thing for a very long time, and we all had to do it. In today's AI world, it's even more important." While u/Traditonal_Put_8254 pointed out, "NTA. Following directions is a skill in and of itself, and the teacher needs to see HOW they are working through the problem to be able to head off any potential issues with comprehension later (such as a child who consistently gets the right answer using a flawed version of the taught method that may no longer work once more advanced topics are studied)."
Teacher sends emotional note to parents after 50% students fail to finish 'simple' assignment
Short poem captures why poor kids often struggle with school rules: 'Cause I ain't got no pencil'