Four years ago, dues were $158 a month. Then homeowner dues were hiked to $350 for a pool that was never built — now their HOA wants $1,250
Just four years ago, the dues were $158. Within a short span, the homeowners have witnessed the costs increase to almost eight times.
Inside Magnolia Cove, a quiet lakeside community tucked in Sherrills Ford, homeowner Jill Menson spent nights crying. This is not what she signed up for. Dozens of homeowners in the same community are going through the same feeling ever since their Homeowners Association (HOA) jacked up the dues from $350 to a whopping $1,250, with a $10,000 special assessment. Their avoidance of any explanation further stirred up an uproar. The letter prompted residents to file a lawsuit against the HOA, according to a June 20, 2026 report by WSOCTV9. As the legal battle continues, residents are going through a rollercoaster of “heartbreak and helplessness."
Guardian not God
Just four years ago, the dues were $158. Within a short span, the homeowners have witnessed the costs increase to almost eight times. Worse yet, when the residents signed up for the HOA, they were promised that the amount would be utilized for a community pool and routine lawn maintenance, none of which was ever executed. Since many of the retirees in the community live on fixed income, this sudden hike in the dues is imposing a great burden upon their shoulders.
Big fuss over a trifle
Tight budgets are not the only reason for the residents’ unease and frustration. There are also structural disparities. Only around 20 of the community’s 80 houses are occupied by their owners; the rest are just rentals. Resident Stephanie Roebuck never expected to move into a community like this when she bought her house. Mike Brokaw believes that the tussle could have been avoided entirely. If the HOA had maintained basic financial transparency and answered residents’ questions with clarity, there would have been no need to file the ongoing litigation.
Totalitarian-style terror
According to The Cool Down, several HOAs across the country have also faced angst of the homeowners for prohibiting cost-effective home upgrades such as rooftop solar panels and native plant lawns. Residents of Magnolia Cove believe that the HOA is trying to assert a “declarant control” over their own properties. To make matters worse, the developer of this community is also the HOA’s president, which has left the homeowners even more powerless and tongue-tied in the money matters.
When homeowners reached out for transparency and clarity, they were dismissed. Their last resort was to file a lawsuit, which is exactly what they did. The developer counterclaimed and declared their litigation an excuse for “defamation.” A jury even tried to punish four neighbours with millions of dollars for speaking out. The four residents created a GoFundMe page with a $30,000 target to cover the legal costs. Meanwhile, HOA’s attorney, H. Weldon Jones III, laid out a different narrative. He told WSOC that the steep hike in the dues was necessary to keep HOA operations funded. He reinforced his argument by adding that some homeowners have failed to pay the dues for the past few years and others have stopped paying altogether.
What’s the solution?
As of now, the residents only have two choices apart from waiting for the results of the lawsuit. They can either craft a proposal that will decide how long the developer can exert control over an association. Second, they can approach House Bill 444, according to which the HOA would be barred from raising ratified common-expense budgets by more than 5% without majority owner approval.
The cost of control
Magnolia Cove's residents aren't alone in feeling frustrated with their HOA. A survey of more than 1,000 American homeowners by 2-10 found that while 60% had positive experiences with their HOAs, 54% mentioned encountering challenges. For one-third of respondents, those experiences were so bad, it made them want to leave their neighborhood. The biggest complaints included unreasonable fees, inconsistent rule enforcement, and poor communication. And despite the benefits some homeowners see in HOAs, 70% said they would prefer to live in a community without one if they were buying a home today.
Like daylight robbery
Viewers were just as mortified as the residents upon hearing what the HOA has been doing to them. @elsierodgers4874 commented, “They're running a scam there.” @donm3844 said, “The reason to never buy a home with a HOA.” @tsukuba48 remarked, “HOAs are supposed to save property values. Now HOAs are destroying the values.”
More on Scoop Upworthy
HOA fined him $50 a day for a 'dirty' car but his comeback wiped the HOA clean off their high horse
HOA kept complaining that woman's lawn was not green enough — so she complied maliciously
Share on Facebook
