Customer asked for a 'plain cheeseburger' at Five Guys, then complained there was nothing on it. His 'McDonald’s' demand made it even stranger

Fast-food menu jargon is usually a bit annoying for hungry diners, but a simple order at Five Guys recently turned into a pure customer service absurdity. When an employee (u/50calTaco) asked a customer about preferred toppings, he insisted on a "plain, regular cheeseburger." Following instructions, the worker handed over a simple bun, patty, and cheese burger, satisfied to have completed the order. However, a minute later, the customer returned, furious that his burger had no toppings. The situation escalated when he brought McDonald’s into his defense. The post, shared on September 27, 2026, has received over 27,000 upvotes on Reddit.

A 'plain, regular cheeseburger'

The employee explained that at Five Guys, every burger is custom-built, meaning customers can select their preferred toppings, justifying the higher price tag. After ringing up this grown man’s order, the worker clearly asked about his preferred toppings, and he insisted on a "plain, regular cheeseburger."

Taking the request literally, as is standard practice across the fast-food industry, the kitchen prepared a cheeseburger with zero additional toppings. Just a minute after receiving his meal, the customer returned to the counter, visibly annoyed. "You made my food wrong. There’s nothing on it," he told the worker. 

McDonald’s to his defense

When the employee politely pointed out that he had requested a plain cheeseburger, the customer fired back, "I did. Do you not know what that means? Like a McDonald’s burger". The employee offered to remake the meal in the house and asked what toppings he actually wanted.  The customer testily listed off his idea of a "plain McDonald's" burger: ketchup, lettuce, and pickles, a combination that matches neither a plain burger nor a standard McDonald's cheeseburger. 

Customer service chaos

This story highlights a prominent issue in the quick-service food industry, where restaurant workers often make order blunders. According to a survey shared by Restaurant Business Online, more than 1,000 customers (9 out of 10) have experienced a food order going wrong, creating a constant culture of customer skepticism where staff are mostly assumed to be in the wrong. Such mistakes happen often and get resolved quickly, with 47% of people simply reordering from the same restaurant and moving on.

Meanwhile, 4 in 10 customers got so pissed that they ordered from somewhere else. Although the worker in the Reddit post didn't mess up the order, they were still blamed. "He got what he wanted in the end, and I apologized because customer service, but like? I’m in awe at the sheer level of misunderstanding and audacity," the worker added.

Netizens supported the Five Guys worker, expressing utter disbelief at the customer's flawed logic and sharing their own retail nightmare stories. u/Worldly_Cry_6652 wrote, "Imagine being that wrong and so sure you are right." u/RebekkaKat1990 revealed, "When I worked for Domino's, I had a customer order an Ultimate Pepperoni pizza with extra pepperoni and extra cheese, which is already a pizza that gets extra pepperoni and extra cheese. When they got it delivered, they called back to complain that their pizza was 'too greasy.' Like, no shit? You ordered the greasiest possible pizza and expected no grease?"

More on Scoop Upworthy

Internet applauds Subway staff's savage response to woman who was screaming at them

'Please don't come back': Shop owner’s epic stand against abusive customer has her staff cheering

Customers left a rude note instead of a tip — all because waitress asked one customary question