NEWS
LIFESTYLE
FUNNY
WHOLESOME
INSPIRING
ANIMALS
RELATIONSHIPS
PARENTING
WORK
SCIENCE AND NATURE
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy
SCOOP UPWORTHY is part of
GOOD Worldwide Inc. publishing
family.
© GOOD Worldwide Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Couple were planning for a baby when husband got FB message claiming he had a 5-year-old son — but his plan for the boy left his wife disappointed

'He always imagined that his children would be with me,' she wrote

Couple were planning for a baby when husband got FB message claiming he had a 5-year-old son — but his plan for the boy left his wife disappointed
Man in blue sweater looking distressed. (Representative Cover Image Source: Pexels | Photo by Antoni Shkraba)

Life has a way of throwing curveballs and changing even the best-laid plans. On August 22, 2016, a 29-year-old woman (u/lovechild5346) took to Reddit to vent about her husband David's situation. The couple had been together for six years and married for three, with no kids. However, her husband recently found out he had a 5-year-old son with Jessica, a woman from his past. She was shocked and angry by the discovery, but her emotions quickly changed to sadness and disappointment when David told her what he planned to do. The post has received 324 upvotes and 99 comments so far.

Initial reaction

The author and her husband had been married for three years and hoped to have kids of their own in the next two to three years. One day, Jessica messaged David and told him about their 5-year-old son, Alex. But David was not a cheater. He had a casual relationship with Jessica and slept with her once. It happened a month before he started dating the author. Back to the present, David and the author bought a house a year ago and moved to Quebec, but Jessica and Alex were in Ontario. The author knew it wasn't going to be easy maintaining a relationship with his son.

The author had all sorts of thoughts running through her mind. Was Alex really David's son? Does Jessica want their money? But the news hit David hard, too. He broke down in their living room and apologized to her. She shared, "He always imagined that his children would be with me, and that this is not the kind of father he wanted to be." In the heat of the moment, he decided that if it came to that, he would "pay child support, but to not have any presence in his [Alex] life since his future family is with me." He thought his plan would make his wife happy. Instead, she reacted the complete opposite. "You would think this would make me happy, but that actually just makes me even sadder and even more disappointed in my husband."

Letter for the future

On September 10, 2016, the author shared an update. After a home paternity test, David was indeed the father. They had a few more conversations, and the author revealed: "It came out that when he had said that he didn't want to be involved initially, it was because that is what he thought I wanted to hear." She knew her husband would not be happy if he chose to ignore his son's existence.

However, the story took another turn. Alex was living with his stepfather, Sam, after Jenny placed him in foster care due to her frequent fainting spells. Although Jenny had accused Sam of assaulting Alex in 2013, photos and videos online appeared to show them happy together. The author and David felt it would be unfair to separate Alex from the only father figure he knew, but agreed that Jenny was not a safe option. They planned to have a caretaker assess Sam and, if Alex was safe and happy, David would relinquish his parental rights. He would also leave Sam a letter explaining everything to Alex, which Sam could share when he felt the time was right.

Secret pregnancies

In some cases, men don't even know they have a child out there in the world because the mothers refuse to tell them. A 2019 study by Brian T. Nguyen surveyed 903 men, of whom 776 were sexually active a year ago and weren't planning for pregnancy in the next three months. The study found that almost one in six men were involved in an unplanned pregnancy. Another 2012 study by Kara Joyner discovered that 9% of the women surveyed said that they had little or no contact with their baby's father. The study also assumed that there were probably 10% of biological fathers who were not aware they had children because the birth mothers did not tell them about the pregnancy.

Jessica's plan

Image Source: Reddit | u/poekpoek
Image Source: Reddit | u/ltlpunk

Readers figured out Jessica's plan, and the only victims in the story are Alex, David, and Sam. Several people wished the author luck and applauded the way she and David handled the situation. u/FlexNastyBIG wrote, "You're a fantastic person and a fantastic partner for being supportive of David through this." u/vanishplusxzone added, "I'm sorry this happened to you, OP. I'm sorry your husband and Alex have to deal with this sh*tshow, too. Seems that Sam is a victim here as well. Jessica sounds like a nightmare. It sounds like you and David have chosen to take the most mature, responsible, logical, level-headed route you can possibly take in such an ugly, emotionally charged situation. Best wishes."

More on Scoop Upworthy

Brother asked him to write a glowing 'good father' letter for custody court. He refused to tell a lie about something he'd never witnessed

She asked her ex-mother-in-law to postpone daughter's weekend visit. 3 days later, she’d lost custody

Wife fired their nanny for bringing the kids home when their son acted out. Six months later, her husband was left fighting for custody

More Stories on Scoop