Massachusetts couple discover they were baptized together as babies, at the very church where they were to about to marry

For decades, Ryan McGinty and Jessica Connolly sat on the same pews in St. Timothy Catholic Church in Norwood, their names being recorded in the same diocesan books, yet they were entirely oblivious to each other’s existence. Now newlyweds, they found out that their love stories started a long way before they bumped into each other in college. Everyone is fascinated by the stroke of destiny and is wondering what the odds are that a love story could be as beautiful as this, according to an October 20, 2026, report by CBS News. On YouTube, their story has been viewed more than 16,000 times.

What are the odds?

McGinty and Connolly grew up in neighboring regions seven minutes away from each other, in Westwood and Walpole, respectively. They studied in different schools and had different friends. They didn’t meet each other until their junior year in college, when Connolly came to visit her friends on the college campus. "Seven minutes away from each other our whole life, and we didn't know each other," Connolly mused. It was love at first sight, and they knew they’d get married one day.

'That’s pretty special'

While planning their wedding, they came to realize that as newborns, they were baptized in the same church on the same freezing cold February day. Both of them had attended the church their whole lives, never knowing it would become a thread making their love story even deeper than they thought it was. It was the same church where they were going to be married. "I was looking at the registry books, and sure enough, they were baptized together," pastoral associate Michelle Gallo explained. "I decided to look at the other sacraments. Sure enough: first communion, confirmation, and now wedding. What are the odds of that? To think that you were together to receive all those graces four times? That’s pretty special."

Flash forward to the present, the couple feels blessed and lucky to have shared roots and similar childhood experiences. McGinty said they still attend the same church, as his father is a parish lector there. "Even when I'm having a bad day, come home from work, and I'm maybe in a bad mood, I still feel Ryan's love all the time," Connolly said. "You would have a really hard time with all the people that know her to find one person that had a bad thing to say about her," her husband added.

Assortative mating

While Connolly and McGinty may not realize it, their story is an example of what psychologists call “assortative mating.” According to a report by ScienceDirect, it is a tendency of individuals to select partners based on shared or dissimilar physical, genetic, or social traits rather than choosing mates at random. According to the Pew Research Center, a staggering 74% of married U.S. adults share the same religious identity as their spouse.

'There are no coincidences, only God’s plan'

On Instagram, hundreds of people jumped in to celebrate McGinty and Connolly's love story, pouring blessings and positive messages. @back_bay_ali said it was “Perhaps a divine intervention!” @creffel said, “Invisible strings. Congrats.” @ceciliastanford remarked, “I dream of this for my kids! Beautiful story!”

More on Scoop Upworthy

Woman yelled, 'Why is my husband’s photo here?' at a stranger’s yard sale — then found his late mom’s dishes and 20-year-old family photos

Girl found a letter a boy wrote to her mom in high school. Her jaw dropped when she recognized the boy in the photo

They became pen pals in 1984. When they finally met 42 years later, she could still pick him out of an old photo