Woman filmed a cop handcuffing a Wall Street reporter for doing his job outside a bank. 4 years later, that move cost the city $100K
Years after being wrongfully detained by a police officer, Dion Rabouin has been served justice
In November 2022, when an alarmed bystander noticed Phoenix police officer Caleb Zimmerman forcing a man into handcuffs outside a local Chase bank, she pulled out her phone, arguing that Dion Rabouin was just a reporter who had offered to leave peacefully. The officer ignored her pleas and even threatened to arrest the bystander. He unlawfully searched Wall Street Journal reporter Rabouin on the sidewalk and arrested him. Years after the viral standoff and an internal affairs review by the Phoenix Police Department, that split-second decision proved costly, with the city agreeing to a $100,000 settlement with Rabouin, as reported by ABC15 Arizona (@abc15) on September 11, 2026.
A sidewalk standoff
On November 23, 2022, Rabouin was out on the streets to interview people about personal finance and savings rates when Zimmerman arrived. Surprisingly, the police officer handcuffed him because the sidewalk he was standing on was private property. Although Rabouin said, "I will walk away voluntarily," Officer Zimmerman refused to listen. Meanwhile, a female passerby who was watching the incident started recording the entire exchange and even insisted that the officer let go of Rabouin. In the end, she was also threatened with arrest.
Feeling violated by the sudden detention, Rabouin quickly escalated the matter through formal department channels. "The lawsuit would have been prevented with a simple conversation. But in the video, this officer had to be aggressive and put handcuffs on Dion, who's just doing his job as a reporter," Rabouin's attorney Benjamin Taylor argued as they made the matter official. In the official filing report to the Phoenix Police Department, Rabouin alleged that Zimmerman used excessive force, stopped him based on his race, and made unlawful threats of physical assault during the encounter.
The internal review
The department's Internal Affairs Bureau then conducted an inquiry and concluded it by August 2023. While it dismissed most of Rabouin's initial grievances, such as racial bias and excessive force, it uncovered a critical Fourth Amendment breach on its own accord. "The officer legally detained Mr. Rabouin, then identified him by removing a wallet from his pocket. Retrieving Mr. Rabouin’s wallet violated Department search and seizure policy," they wrote in their press release. As a result, the department sent Zimmerman to remedial retraining instead of issuing a written formal reprimand.
After the incident became public, things escalated further. Both Chase Bank and Phoenix Mayor Kate Gallego issued apologies to Rabouin. Nevertheless, the biggest breakthrough, perhaps for Rabouin and his team, came recently when the Phoenix City Council quietly took up the federal investigation on its routine consent agenda and approved a massive $100,000 settlement with a unanimous 9-0 vote. Apart from the monetary relief, Taylor insisted his case be seen as a precedent for police before they decide to violate a journalist's First Amendment rights.
The fear still lingers
Although the department denied Rabouin's arrest was related to his race, only 50% of the African American community report being satisfied with their police encounters. In contrast, 70% of white Americans report being satisfied with their personal police encounters. Additionally, while 27% of African Americans report being stopped by the police two or more times in the past few years, only 18% of white Americans report the same, according to a Cato Institute study.
'The officer should pay'
Meanwhile, reacting to the story, @koolaidpurple suggested, "Settlements should come directly out of officers' pensions." Speaking in a similar tone, @celang1 noted, "They'll keep doing it. They never learn because the money doesn't come out of their pocket."
More on Scoop Upworthy
Share on Facebook
