San Diego’s only female lifeguard captain was blocked from applying for chief. She took that ‘no’ to court

For decades, San Diego’s lifeguard service has been celebrated for its lifesaving traditions. However, behind the scenes, a major leadership shakeup is now sparking serious legal drama. Captain Maureen Hodges, San Diego’s only female lifeguard captain, claims she was shut out of the running for the department's top job without even getting a chance to submit her name. Refusing to accept that "no," she has officially filed a discrimination lawsuit against the city. The story was shared by NBC 7 San Diego on November 12, 2026, and the broadcast quickly racked up nearly 4,000 views.

Second in command, sidelined

Captain Hodges is no newcomer to the sand and surf. She has worked with San Diego lifeguard operations for 20 years and serves as second in command, a role she has held for the past seven years. Along the way, she shattered barriers as the first woman promoted to lieutenant and the only woman ever promoted to captain. When the lifeguard chief position suddenly opened on October 5th following the abrupt departure of Chief James Gartland, given her rank and experience, Hodges expected to be considered for the role. Instead, her attorney, Michael Conger, says the city completely sidelined her. "They didn't let her apply. They didn't let her interview," Conger said.

Bypassing the standard search

The details behind the city's decision are raising eyebrows. According to city records, former Chief James Gartland suddenly left after he and two sergeants mishandled a sexual harassment complaint. Just four days after Gartland's exit, the city bypassed its usual nationwide search and long interview process to appoint Deputy City Attorney Daniel Orloff as the new lifeguard chief. A man who left the lifeguard service back in 2023 and whose highest rank was sergeant years ago. "They picked somebody that his highest rank was a sergeant, you know, years ago," Conger pointed out.

The lawsuit alleges that Hodges' gender and sex were a "substantial motivation" behind the city refusing to let her apply or interview. Her attorney argues that the decision points to a broader culture of discrimination within the service. Conger also clarified that despite being second in command, Hodges "has no involvement in any of that" regarding the mishandled harassment complaint and "didn't witness anything." While a city spokesperson emailed a statement saying, "we have no comment on pending litigation," Hodges remains on the job. Conger noted that his client is asking for the chief position and wants to prove her case to "make the public as proud of internal lifeguard practices as it is its lifesaving traditions."

An uphill swim for women

Hodges' legal battle mirrors a broader reality for women trying to reach the top in male-dominated fields. According to a 2018 study by Pew Research Center, 25% of women working in majority-male workplaces said they had to prove themselves all the time to be respected by coworkers. Only 38% said women were treated fairly in opportunities for promotion and advancement. Furthermore, a U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) report on the federal workforce also identified barriers that can make higher-level and management positions harder for women to obtain, including gaps in mentoring, networking, and developmental opportunities.

'GO GIRL'

In the comment section, most viewers are in support of Captain Hodges, arguing that skipping standard hiring procedures to appoint a lower-ranked man strongly supports her discrimination claim. But a few pushed back on her suitability and defended employer discretion. @yeah_right88 writes, "Not even letting her interview is pretty obvious given the fact the other guy was a lower rank. Makes no sense other than what she is saying." Meanwhile, user @cittiavaticano says, "My general response is not everything is discrimination, but after the story I think there's merit here. Unfortunate. All that can do the job should be considered."

More on Scoop Upworthy

Woman changed her gender on LinkedIn as an experiment. It confirmed something she always suspected

Guy with an economics degree explains the gender pay gap in under a minute and it's brilliant

Woman takes her husband's name after countless interview rejections — and immediately lands a job