NEWS
LIFESTYLE
FUNNY
WHOLESOME
INSPIRING
ANIMALS
RELATIONSHIPS
PARENTING
WORK
SCIENCE AND NATURE
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy
SCOOP UPWORTHY is part of
GOOD Worldwide Inc. publishing
family.
© GOOD Worldwide Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Boss used café worker’s thumbs-up emoji as ‘proof’ she agreed to give up her guaranteed hours. That decision ended up costing them $6,200

Manukonga was abruptly replaced with someone else and told 'Yes, sorry.'

Boss used café worker’s thumbs-up emoji as ‘proof’ she agreed to give up her guaranteed hours. That decision ended up costing them $6,200
Cafe worker writing on her clipboard. (Representative Cover Image Source: Pexels | Photo by Ron Lach)

It began with a routine text message. Sharnika Manukonga, an Auckland café worker, messaged her boss about a six-day house-sitting gig that would keep her from attending work for a week. Her boss replied that she would be shifted to casual status with no guaranteed hours. Manukonga responded with a thumbs-up emoji. Weeks later, when her name vanished from the roster entirely, her employer argued that the yellow thumbs-up emoji proved she had agreed to the deal. The Employment Relations Authority ultimately ordered the café operator to pay her about $6,160 (NZ$11,000) after finding she had been unjustifiably dismissed, according to a November 14, 2026 report by HCA Magazine.

Cafe worker (Representative Image Source: Pexels | Photo by Kadir Yeşilbudak)

Setting the employment terms

Manukonga joined the café operated by Anthony and Emily Limited (A&EL) in early 2025. She had recently finished school and was looking for work. After an interview and a trial shift, they offered her the role. She agreed to work 25 to 35 hours per week, across three to four days. She started working on February 24, 2025, but did not sign her individual employment agreement until March 1, 2025, after completing about three shifts, per Stuff.

Unpleasant experience at work

Describing her initial experience in the job, Manukonga told the Authority that she received very little formal training. Instead, she learned most of the work by observing other staff and asking questions. She said she was being yelled at during shifts and having her eyes rolled at her when she asked questions. From time to time, she was even physically jabbed in the shoulder and back with a finger for speedier performance. Even some of the customers commented on how she was being treated.

Cafe worker (Representative Image Source: Pexels | Photo by Tim Douglas)

In early April 2025, Manukonga messaged her manager and café director, Emily Ma, to inform her that she wouldn’t be available for six days because she was house-sitting and the commute to work would be difficult. Her manager texted her that she had been “put on casual”; her hours couldn’t be guaranteed. When she asked whether she could return to normal hours after the week, Ma’s response was, "I'm not guaranteed. I can only say I can try, not guarantee." Manukonga replied with a thumbs-up emoji. Little did she know that this tiny yellow icon would stir an uproarious battle between her and the employer.

Emoji battle

Manukonga’s employer took the emoji as proof that she agreed to a fundamental change in her employment terms — from guaranteed hours to casual, no-guarantee work. But Manukonga didn’t learn this until April 12, 2025, when a new schedule was released. Her name was nowhere on it. When she questioned, she was told that another employee had been hired full-time to replace her because she "always has something else to do." She reached out to Ma but was told, “Yes, sorry.”

The employer later argued that Manukonga was subject to a 6-month trial period. However, under New Zealand’s Employment Relations Act 2000, the trial period couldn’t be relied upon because Manukonga did not sign the agreement until March 1, after she had already completed about three shifts. The employer cited her smiley-face emojis in the texts, saying that they were evidence that she was not unhappy.

Wooden block and gavel in a court of law (Representative Image Source: Pexels | Photo by EKATERINA BOLOVTSOVA)

Cases of wrongful termination

A thumbs-up emoji has raised similar questions in U.S. courts. In a 2022 New York case, a company argued that a thumbs-up sent during text negotiations proved the other party had accepted a repayment agreement. The court noted that an emoji could potentially serve as an electronic signature, but said there still had to be evidence of a “meeting of the minds” and an intention to be legally bound. Because the surrounding messages left questions about what the sender actually meant, the court declined to treat the emoji alone as conclusive proof of agreement.

Whopping penalty

Meanwhile, after hearing both sides of the argument, the Authority awarded Manukonga about $1,980 (NZ$3,578.29) in lost wages, calculated at the worker's rate of about $12.98 (NZ$23.50) per hour for 25 hours per week over 10 weeks. It also awarded about $3,870 (NZ$7,000) in compensation for humiliation, loss of dignity, and injury to feelings, plus about $325 (NZ$587.50) for the one week's notice the employer failed to provide, totaling about $6,170 (NZ$11,165.79).

More on Scoop Upworthy

Boss fired employee 1 week after she disclosed she was pregnant. She used the termination letter to take him to court

The employee woke up to a 'Termination' email and froze — until he read the rest. He headed straight to HR

HR accidentally sent a 'termination' letter to 300 workers — including the CEO

More Stories on Scoop