NEWS
LIFESTYLE
FUNNY
WHOLESOME
INSPIRING
ANIMALS
RELATIONSHIPS
PARENTING
WORK
SCIENCE AND NATURE
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy
SCOOP UPWORTHY is part of
GOOD Worldwide Inc. publishing
family.
© GOOD Worldwide Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Boss fired café worker over ‘unfriendly’ texts lacking smiley-face emojis and dared her to complain to the authorities. She did just that

'Fire her right now! I don't care about the cost; do it now,' Wang screamed, angry over a silly little issue

Boss fired café worker over ‘unfriendly’ texts lacking smiley-face emojis and dared her to complain to the authorities. She did just that
Worker in an apron standing behind her still with a poker face (Representative Cover Image Source: Pexels | Photo by Kampus Production)

When Queensland café worker Kristen Gordon texted her boss, Phoebe Wang, about staff shortages, she committed a fatal sin: she forgot to add an emoji. To her manager, it wasn’t a casual omission or just her texting style; it was the start of a cold, relentless war. In fact, witnesses saw the manager smash her phone and scream about the immediate execution of the innocent worker. Gordon brazenly challenged her manager, approached the Fair Work Commission (FWC), and claimed a penalty of $3,618 ($5,357 AUD) and more, according to a July 14, 2022, Newsweek report.

Smiling waitress serving cup of coffee (Representative Image Source: Getty Images | Photo by Ljubaphoto)

Working around IVF

For the past 14 months, Gordon had been working as a supervisor at Sens Coffee in Queensland, owned by Sens Catering Group. Gordon’s duties included rostering and timesheets, according to 7 News. At this time, Gordon was also undergoing IVF (in vitro fertilization) treatment, and the question of whether she could work during this period came up. She then informed her manager, Wang, and requested leave on certain days because of the procedure. She clarified that, apart from these days, she could indeed work because "money was more important than ever during this time." Gordon also shared that she could perform all her duties apart from lifting milk crates from the fridge.

A businesswoman in office using smartphone and enjoying coffee. (Representative Image Source: Pexels | Photo by RDNE Stock project)

A shocking outburst

Then, on March 12, she expressed her disagreement with staff rostering decisions in a group text between the café managers. Gordon argued that the managers should hire more staff for their other outlet, the Goya Café shop, instead of sending staff from Sens Coffee, leaving it understaffed. Gordon’s text evoked fury in Wang, so much so that she "smashed her phone on the counter" and "jumped up and down while screaming." In an outburst of anger, Wang told the other shop manager, "Fire her right now! Hire another supervisor. I don't care about the cost; do it now!"

When another manager asked Wang why she was so angry, she replied that Gordon "didn't add any smiley faces" and "there are no emotions." When another employee saw the texts, they found them normal, but Wang argued that the café worker was being rude. Gordon was fired the next day. One week after her dismissal, the ex-supervisor said Wang offered Gordon two weeks of paid leave and a position running a new store, but she refused. Wang said, "Obviously they cannot work together because they do not have the same values."

A professional lawyer in a formal setting working on a laptop with a gavel in focus on the desk. (Representative Image Source: Pexels | Photo by Sora Shimazaki)

A costly dismissal

At one point, Wang brazenly provoked the dismissed café worker to approach the FWC and said she didn’t care. That’s exactly what Gordon did. Fair Work Commissioner Chris Simpson found the ex-supervisor innocent. He said the ex-employee had only expressed a view on staffing in favor of the business but was sacked for disagreeing with owners. "The evidence does not support a conclusion that the applicant refused to follow a lawful and reasonable direction, and there is nothing else to support a conclusion that her actions constituted a valid reason for dismissal," he said.

Gordon is not the only person to have experienced an unfair and unjust termination; in fact, nearly 16,500 unfair dismissal claims were filed between 2024 and 2025, according to Maddocks. But only about 2% to 3% of unfair dismissal claims reach formal hearing, per Fair Workplace Solutions. The outlet stated that around 78% of unfair dismissal cases resolve successfully at conciliation, with proper preparation. In Gordon's case, the FWC ruled in Gordon's favor in July 2022. The FWC ordered Sens Catering Group to pay Gordon $5,357 AUD ($3,618) as well as 9.5 percent superannuation on that amount paid into her nominated superannuation fund.

More on Scoop Upworthy

Boss used café worker’s thumbs-up emoji as ‘proof’ she agreed to give up her guaranteed hours. That decision ended up costing them $6,200

Fired over a simple cheek kiss, a 60-year-old social worker lost her home and health. With no lawyer, she fought her employer alone and won

The honest worker told HR she had overpaid them by $3,000. The company reversed $8,500, bounced her mortgage — and then said it had every right to

More Stories on Scoop