A meteorite hit her $400 car in 1992. She sold the wreck for $10,000 and the rock for $50,000
'Criminal mischief by a very strong male,' the local cops originally wrote.
When someone hears a deafening smash outside their house, they assume the worst of the local drivers. Maybe someone backed out blindly, or a reckless teenager took the corner too fast and totaled your bumper. But on the night of October 9, 1992, 18-year-old Michelle Knapp ran out of her Wells Street home in Peekskill, New York, to find something far stranger than a hit-and-run. Her red 1980 Chevy Malibu was crumpled in the driveway, smelling heavily of sulfur. Tucked into a crater beneath the trunk sat a football-sized rock, still hot to the touch. It wasn't a reckless neighbor; it was the Peekskill Meteorite, a visitor from deep space that the runabout turned into a profit of over $60,000, as reported by the Peekskill Herald on October 9, 2022. The bizarre incident resurfaced again on October 9, 2026, its 34th anniversary, when outlets including People and Space.com revisited the story of the meteorite that turned Knapp’s battered car into a piece of scientific history.
A streaking green fireball
Before it touched ground, the meteor lit up the Eastern Seaboard during a brisk Friday night. High school football stadiums suddenly felt silent as players and fans looked up to witness a dazzling, emerald-tinted streak tearing across the clouds. Dads in the bleachers grabbed their camcorders, filming the bright trail of fragments for nearly ten seconds, per Peekskill Herald, as it blazed from Kentucky and North Carolina all the way to New York. During this time, Knapp was relaxing on her sofa watching television when an explosive crash rocked the house.
The impact on Wells Street
She thought two or three cars had smashed together right outside her Wells Street house. So Knapp rushed onto the driveway, only to discover the crumpled rear bumper of her 1980 Chevy Malibu, surrounded by a harsh, sulfurous odor. Resting in a shallow six-inch pit straight beneath the car frame was a football-sized, charred rock that was "still warm and smelling of sulfur." Soon, the local police officers showed up at her house. They were also baffled when they first saw the punctured metal. So much so that they chalked the incident up to severe vandalism. "Criminal mischief by a very strong male," they originally wrote.
#OTD in 1992, the Peekskill meteorite fell just a short distance from NYC. A rock the size of a bowling ball fell from the sky onto a parked Chevy Malibu, piercing the trunk & denting the driveway beneath it. Soon after, it was found near the car, still warm & smelling of sulfur. https://t.co/SzxaBER9om
— American Museum of Natural History (@AMNH) October 9, 2019
Science confirms the strike
The truth, however, emerged over the next few days when geologists stepped in. Columbia University professors quickly tied the smoldering driveway rock to the dozens of fireball sightings across the East Coast. A Herald photographer captured images of scientists and officers examining the car, later reflecting on how rare the moment was. “I remember thinking at the time this kind of stuff doesn't happen here. The damage to the car was significant and clearly was something dropping from above," he later revealed.
An unexpected windfall
For Knapp, the meteor turned out to be a blessing in disguise. She had bought the beat-up Malibu from her grandmother for just $400 only weeks prior. Following the craze, she managed to flip the totaled vehicle for a whopping $10,000, while a trio of meteorite collectors shelled out another $50,000 for the stone itself. The dented sedan turned into an international curiosity, traveling on exhibition tours to museums in Tokyo, Munich, and Paris. Decades later, the fateful strike remains a point of community pride. Even though the Wells' home had since changed hands, passersby remember the point.
Monitor the space
This iconic incident sheds light on how the American masses view NASA and where the government should focus when it comes to space. According to an AP NORC survey, 68% of U.S. adults believe that the U.S. space program should focus on monitoring asteroids, comets, meteorites, and other events in space that could impact Earth, just like what happened in Peekskill. Meanwhile, another 59% think that the program should conduct scientific research and expand humankind's knowledge of space and Earth.
Peekskill remembers
As for the people of Peekskill, even those who were alive to witness this still remember the incident. They took to a Facebook post by ABC7 NY to express their thoughts. Venus Ventura wrote, "I lived close by at the time, went to see the car, and inside they had some men with lab suits weighing pieces of meteorite that residents had, and pay you... I was looking around for a piece." At the same time, Michael Rozanski recalled, "I was 12 on my way back from 'Upper Deck,' a baseball card and comic store on Washington Street lol. I remember walking by when I saw Channel 7 news there."
More on Scoop Upworthy
Share on Facebook
